I rely on sql-metadata for SQL parsing in analytics pipelines and wanted to contribute a small readability pass on the core package while running ShipGate for a broader quality picture.

Summary

ShipGate reported 72 format issues (mostly trailing whitespace in test SQL fixtures) and ~124 refactoring opportunities (strict pass) on a full-repo scan. Security scans and duplication checks were clean; the main themes are cyclomatic complexity in column_extractor / parser, large module sizes, and optional strict-refactor simplifications. This PR applies an auto-fix pass on the production package plus ruff formatting on a handful of test files where line-length and whitespace were noisy.

Hotspots and improvement notes below are scoped to Python (*.py) source.

What you are doing right

• Security: No secrets or high-severity security patterns flagged (gitleaks/bandit/semgrep clean in scope).
• Duplication: No significant clone duplication reported — jscpd looked clean.
• Test discipline: 272 tests pass locally with 100% coverage on sql_metadata; mypy strict mode on the package is green.
• Architecture: Clear v3 extractor composition (ColumnExtractor, TableExtractor, NestedResolver) with lazy caching on the Parser facade — well documented in ARCHITECTURE.md.
• Tooling: Modern ruff + mypy + Poetry CI across Python 3.10–3.14 is solid.

What you could improve

• Maintainability / complexity: _handle_cte and _handle_alias in column_extractor.py rank C on cyclomatic complexity (CC 11–12); values_dict in parser.py is similar — incremental helper extraction would help over time.
• Module size: column_extractor.py (~900 lines), nested_resolver.py, and parser.py exceed typical module-size gates — consider splitting by clause type when the next feature lands.
• Dead code: NoReturn import in query_type_extractor.py appears unused (vulture) — safe cleanup follow-up.
• Refactoring (follow-up): ~100+ strict refactor hints remain in core modules — mostly assign-if-exp, walrus, and regex group indexing; many are optional style wins.
• Test fixtures: Trailing whitespace in multi-line SQL strings in several test files triggers ruff W291 — make format on test/ would clear most of the 72 format findings.

Changes

• Use regex match indexing (match[1]) instead of .group(1) in parser.py and sql_cleaner.py.
• Simplify ternary / walrus patterns in column_extractor.py, generalizator.py, and table_extractor.py.
• Ruff-format test modules with long fixture lines and trailing whitespace.

We're testing ShipGate on real-world projects to learn whether it works well in practice. This review summary was generated from ShipGate check output and AI-assisted analysis. This is not spam, and our intention is not to waste your time or energy — we would genuinely welcome your feedback on the findings or approach. docs.

Full ShipGate findings: review gist